by Jerry Peck - Codeman on Wed Sep 15, 2010 5:53 pm
Hi Raquel,
There are so many choices because there are so many design possibilities that the designers (architects) need choices to select from, such as wood frame, metal frame, masonry partition, whether there are chases or not, single layer or double layer, mechanically attached or adhesive, 1-5/8" stud, 3-5/8" studs, 5-5/8" studs, etc.
Additionally, there are fire rated walls which are STC rated and fire rated wall which are not STC rated, and fire rated walls with various STC ratings.
If you are building a simple structure (and even "simple structure" means many things to many people) then you would most likely the select a fire rated wall design based on the method of construction you were using, then consider if you needed or wanted an STC rating and how high of an STC rating.
Then you need to consider the penetrations "into" or "through" the fire rated wall, i.e., "into" would be a "membrane penetration" which would include items such as electrical boxes, clothes dryer boxes and clothes washer boxes, while "through" would be a "through penetration" and would include items such as duct work, piping, wiring, and the like running one side of the wall through the wall and out the other side of the wall.
While your question may seem like a simple question which should have a simple answer, the answer is really quite complex and depends on what you are building, what you want, and how much money is in the budget.
Jerry Peck - CodeMan
AskCodeMan.com
Construction Litigation Consultant - Retired
Construction and Code Consultant - Semi Retired